Tag Archives: abuse

The Most Abusive Character in Film. Stanley Kubrick’s Jack Torrance in The Shining.

Sneering, snarling, completely lost. (Image by author)

Great films give us great characters for good or bad. Scorsese has more than his share. And while he sometimes includes a big fat hint in the title — Raging Bull, Goodfellas, The Wolf of Wall Street — we all go on quoting and posting gifs of these truly awful people being awful. But Kubrick? His evil is truly evil. Whether it’s the desecration of Gene Kelly’s Singin’ in The Rain in a rape scene in A Clockwork Orange, or HAL 9000’s inability to accept fault and ensuing murderous rampage to cover up his mistake, Kubrick chills with his unblinking camera and meticulous craft. These antiheroes stay with us because they are so real.

And Jack Torrance in The Shining is perhaps the most real of all onscreen abusers. Whatever “shined” at the Overlook Hotel, Jack Torrance was always a dangerous man, the Overlook simply emphasized all that was twisted in him.

I once heard that all Kubrick films can be summed up as: The dehumanization of man by [fill in the blank]. In Dr. Strangelove and 2001, it’s technology. In Paths of Glory and Full Metal Jacket, it’s war. Lolita and Eyes Wide Shut are about sex. In Barry Lyndon it’s society. The Shining, dir. Stanley Kubrick, 1980, is about a man dehumanized by masculinity, or a specific version of it. The utterly antisocial and toxic kind.

Kubrick let us know that from the beginning. Look at the character of his wife Wendy (Shelley Duvall) in the beginning speaking with the doctor about she and Jack’s (Jack Nicholson) son. Danny (Danny Lloyd), blacked out and fell in the bathroom. She is pale and thin and chain smoking. When asked about her family’s recent move to Colorado, we learn that Jack had gotten drunk and dislocated Danny’s arm at their old home in Vermont. She diminishes the incident as “you know, just one of those things,” and smiles when she announces that Jack hasn’t touched a drink since then.

We are immediately told that Jack a threat. A man who won’t simply move his family from Vermont to Colorado to escape his misdeeds, he then proceeds to isolate them further by accepting the winter caretaker position at the Overlook Hotel. A hotel the manager told Jack was inaccessible during winter, the subject of a feud with native tribes, and had a recent winter caretaker who murdered his wife and two daughters with an axe and then killed himself with a shotgun.

“Cozy!” Wendy declares of the cramped area they’ll be forced to live in while at the hotel. While the kitchen, which she’s immediately sent to with Mr. Hallorann (Scatman Cruthers), an older black man, is immense and industrial. The polar opposite of a family kitchen.

Jack’s escalation to violence doesn’t take long, about a month going by the startling screen cards announcing the day of the week. His stated intention in taking the job is to write a book. We only ever see Wendy doing any caretaking of the hotel.Β  Whether she’s checking the boilers, cooking and bringing food to Jack, looking after or playing with Danny or communicating with the local forest rangers about the impassable roads and downed phone lines, she’s engaging in life. Meanwhile Jack plays with his handballs in the large hall he’s staked out as his writing area.

As Wendy, Danny and Jack become more isolated, the worse Jack becomes. It’s as though the release from society and its norms with checks on behavior releases something in Jack. That something is alluded to on the family drive to the hotel: what The Donner Party became after they were left snowbound in the mountains. Worse than animals. Degraded and depraved humanity.

Jack begins with agitated hostility. When Wendy enters the hall to check on him, he orders her out, telling her to leave him alone “and . . . start now by getting the fuck out.” Wendy really has no response to his casual cruelty than to suck in her breath and leave. She isn’t a person to him. Neither is Danny.

When Jack does make his “deal with the devil,” declaring “[he’d] sell his soul for a goddamned glass of beer,” he’s crude with the approving bartender who appears, Lloyd (Joe Turkel). Wendy is “the old sperm bank,” and Danny is “the little fucker.” Danny spread his papers all over his office, so Jack just pulled him away so dislocating his shoulder was Danny’s fault, he explains. Jack complains of “The White Man’s Burden.” Later on, Mr. Hallorann is referred to as “a n—-r cook.” The Bartender says, “Women. Can’t live with them.” Leaving the usual end of the phrase ominously missing.

Meanwhile the film reminds us of the rape of the native lands in the hotel’s faux native decor. Alcohol and alcoholism mark Jack’s degeneration. And when Wendy and Danny go into the hedge maze, we are reminded of the illogical, isolated and frightening situation they are in.

After the snowstorm, and Danny’s apparently violent experience in one of the hotel rooms, Jack grows worse. He treats checking out the room as an annoying interruption. And after having encountered one of his demons in what appears at first to be a beautiful naked woman, he lies to Wendy. He gaslights her into wondering if Danny really is the problem and if she is just being dramatic. In the meantime, Jack pulls the transistors from the radio to the forest service, and destroys the “snow cat” that Wendy said she could drive while touring the hotel.

All this time, Wendy had been keeping up appearances. She kept wearing cute but warm outfits and makeup, which Danny uses in the “Redrum” scene. Making breakfast in bed for Jack. She is the perfect picture of an abused woman. She’s completely isolated with a man she knows can be violent and has a volatile temper. She has no way to contact anyone, and she cannot leave her circumstances. She’s trying her best to keep it together and keep him calm.

Jack rubs her face in the situation when, after finally deciding to leave the hotel in the unbeknownst to her destroyed snow cat for the now catatonic Danny’s sake, Jack yells to her to “Go check it out! You’re not going anywhere, Wendy!”

Wendy eventually realizes her survival and that of Danny requires her to do something drastic. With luck she manages to confine Jack for a while, but when he gets out, she shoves Danny through a tiny window in their bathroom. She looks doomed until Mr. Hallorann, the only person who thought to check on the family, pulls up in another snow cat. After murdering Hallorann with an axe, Jack chases Danny out into the snow.

Here Jack, now howling unintelligibly and barely walking, is outwitted by Danny’s knowledge of the hedge maze. Wendy loads Danny into Hallorann’s snow cat, and they leave. Jack is left completely alone and frozen to death.

Jack Torrance is a terrifying character who believes his own feelings override that of any other character in the film. He dislocates Danny’s shoulder because he’s drunk and late. He relocates his family across the US to avoid his actions and their repercussions. His wife, who is a shy bookworm, is left alone with their son in a new town where neither she nor Danny have friends or support, except through insufficient institutional support in a kind female doctor. Jack blames Wendy for his unrealized dreams of becoming a writer, and further isolates her and their son by agreeing to live in the inaccessible and creepy Overlook Hotel. Jack’s pursuit of alcohol and women, his lack of respect for his wife and care for his son are the demons that drive him to his cold, lonely end.

Jack was always as he was and allowed and encouraged to be by the history represented in the film. He was always frozen on the inside. He wanted to be alone. Unfortunately, he was thinking of John Houston or John Wayne. Instead he was just a little man crippled inside and then without, whose only real contribution to society ended up being reams of all cap type complaining that “All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy.”

NamastΓ© you shining legends.

– JL βœŒπŸΌβ€οΈπŸ§‘πŸ’›πŸ’šπŸ©΅πŸ’™πŸ’œπŸ€ŽπŸ–€πŸ©ΆπŸ€πŸ˜³

If you or anyone you know is experiencing domestic/sexual violence please contact RAIIN by phone or chat.

If you’re considering suicide, self harm, or have a mental health crisis: call or text 988 any time to talk or text with someone from the National Suicide Prevention and Crisis Hotline. Help is always available in English or Spanish.

Check out my Instagram!! And connect with me on Facebook here and here. I’m now on Threads, too!

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

Buy me a cup of coffee and Abbey a homemade peanut butter bone?

Make a monthly donation

Make a yearly donation

Choose an amount

$1.00
$5.00
$10.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00

Or enter a custom amount

$

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly

Got a COMMENT? Click below! I love the feedback. If you like what you’ve read, TAP the Star LIKE button. LIKE and SHARE on Facebook. Follow and share!


Stop Explaining Yourself. Why explaining ourselves to Gaslighters, bullies, and abusers never works.

Image created by author with Nightcafe AI.

There are two types of people we will meet in the world. There are the folks who don’t get us, or we them, and it’s not a big deal. Just move along. Then there are the ones who do get us. Which sounds perfect. Generally, these are folks we can talk and joke with, be honest and ourselves around. We can disagree, but generally without intending harm, and difference is welcome.

Unfortunately, not everyone who “gets us” is in it for friendship or love. Sometimes the people who understand us best are the ones who use that knowledge against us.

Those who treat us as less than, undeserving, and make us feel small usually know us very well. Just like a conman can choose their “mark” from a crowd, or a poker player can read another player’s “tell,” these types, sometimes called “dark empaths,” have us pegged and they’ll use that understanding against us.

Don’t feel bad if you find yourself in this situation. Usually, it’s a backhanded recognition of our strengths. Strengths they may not have, and envy. But we still need to equip ourselves to handle this insidious form of psychological manipulation.

The most vulnerable to attack in this way are “people pleasers.” We want to do good, keep the peace, and make others happy. We were probably brought up that way. Very young children usually believe that bad things are their fault. This causes overwhelming feelings of self-doubt, shame, self-loathing, and can follow us to an early grave (those of us with Trauma, Depression, Anxiety have worse health outcomes than the general population).

That pain can lead us to think that we are, at our core, somehow essentially wrong. That we’re guilty of all sorts of horrors, and it’s only a matter of time until others notice and we receive our just punishment. People who want to control us, put us down, and keep us there know this intuitively. It’s as though they know exactly where we hurt and insist on poking that spot.

Many of us become angry, reclusive, depressed, hyper vigilant, rigid, and constantly on edge looking for the next threat. On some level we may understand that the problem is not with us, but we may not know how to successfully turn this understanding into healing and separation from our tormentors within and without.

Once we realize that the person we trusted, loved, and probably stood up for despite our own welfare is undermining and Gaslighting us, we tend to go on the defense. We want to prove that we are good, deserving, and loveable just as we are. Of course, one of the main elements of Gaslighting is to deny our version of events, question our memories, our intelligence, and our sanity.

We may write down what others say to us that hurts so that we can prove to ourselves and the world that we are not crazy, or bad, evil, or selfish.

We could document conversations, remember specific phrases, or instances so we can say: “Look. I’ve written it all down. I took screenshots. I have it on video.”

But ultimately, all that self explaining will not be effective on a person out to use and/or Gaslight us into submission and agreement. The reason this does not work is not that the other person lacks understanding, it’s because they understand precisely what they are doing. In fact, they may outright deny or claim not to remember what we are talking about. They will only become more adamant in their judgement against us the more evidence and defence we provide. And they will most likely twist that information to their advantage.

So how do we escape that trap? First, we need to understand that, despite the protests of the other, that they are the problem. Their hurts, insecurities, fears are being reflected onto us to lift their own poor self confidence or self concept. Since they actually do get us in a profound way, we could earn the Nobel Peace Prize, yet these folks would find a way to discredit the prize, the achievement, and use it against us.

Secondly, we may attempt to “unmask” these people publicly. To gain enough of the world’s sympathy for our cause that we can bring our tormentors to account. This is not wrong in itself. The #MeToo movement, and the revelations of the extent of child abuse by the Catholic Church and other clergy are positive examples of how, with a lot of inner strength, effort, and the right allies, the powerful (even if they are only powerful in our minds) can be brought to account.

What we need to accept, above all else, is that we are, in fact, OK. That all people make bad decisions, act foolishly, accidentally burp at the dinner table or fart in church. But these people don’t seem to suffer for their humanity like we do. They embrace their silly, weird, awkward, and sometimes painful, unflattering, or boring parts of themselves. Because all people are burping, farting weirdos who do embarrassing dances or sing bad karaoke at a party.

Once we begin to see how much more like other people we are, it becomes easier to forgive and, most importantly, love ourselves. The spell of the Gaslighter may never fully be undone, but we can minimize their power. And, just as we would go to the doctor for antibiotics, there are people who specialize in helping broken people heal. And what needs healing is usually the heart. And it’s helpful to have a professional to guide us.

That is why therapists demonstrate unconditional positive regard for their clients. They are not there to lecture you. They’re there to help you to come to understand yourself and love yourself. With the guidance of a good therapist we can learn to embrace ourselves, farts and burps and embarrassing singing included.

As we learn to love and celebrate ourselves, we will learn self-confidence, and the freedom to simply exist as we are without excuses. We may take up an instrument and play it badly, but enjoy playing anyway. Our yearly karaoke serenade at a Christmas party could become a high point of good natured fun and pride in our shared foibles. And what could be more vulnerable yet human than dancing? But mainly, we will learn that what we’ve been told by others who enjoy our confusion and pain are lies.

So, let’s stop explaining ourselves. Don’t feed the predators any more information or attention. Starve them until they either seek help for their own damaged selves, or turn on someone else. Don’t cast your pearls before swine. Save them for the folks who love us: bad singing, stamp collecting, Klingon Cosplaying, wool dying, wilderness forager, Magic card enthusiast, whatever it is that makes us the unique and improbable people we are.

And remember. So far as we know, we are the only species in the vast Universe that can reflect on ourselves, our world, and Universe. We live on a magnificent oasis in the desert of space and time. Our lives, however long or short, matter because space is big, time is long, but we get the privilege of just being here now. Spend your time with people who get you and love you as you are. And once you learn to love yourself, spread it around.

Namaste, you legends!

– JL βœŒπŸΌπŸ’™πŸ’›πŸ––πŸΌπŸŽΈπŸ’πŸŒžπŸŒŒ

If you’re considering suicide, self harm, or have a mental health crisis: call or text 988 any time to talk or text with someone from the National Suicide Prevention and Crisis Hotline. Help is always available in English or Spanish.

Check out myΒ Instagram!! And connect with me on FacebookΒ hereΒ andΒ here.

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

Buy me coffee? Every five cents goes to fight climate change!

Make a monthly donation

Make a yearly donation

Choose an amount:

$3.00
$5.00
$10.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00
$5.00
$15.00
$100.00

Or enter a custom amount:

$

Thanks for your contribution!

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

DonateDonateDonate

Got a COMMENT? Click below! I love the feedback. If you like what you’ve read, TAP the Star LIKE button below. LIKE and SHARE on Facebook. Follow and share on Twitter!


And then the cops broke in my door: My experience of America’s Culture Wars, Part 4.

All five foot one-ish of my dangerous self hauled off in cuffs. 11pm, November 9th, 2021

The day I described in my last installment of this series, and the citation I received, were not the end of my former neighbors’ abuse and harassment. But let us rewind a bit.

I had managed to get the male neighbor cited once by a nice young officer who was very sensitive and well trained. The neighbors were outside doing this elaborate, loud play acting…about me. They mocked my disability, accused me of being a “Welfare Queen” — thanks for that Ronald McDonald Reagan. It went on for a while, so I called the police.

I had gotten mostly the same responses from the other officers I met. “He’s got free speech.” πŸ™„ Yes, freedom of speech. The First Amendment, and the least understood. Folks are fond of saying “Freedom ain’t free.” And I suppose they imagine bravely standing up to tyranny. To me it is basic causality. Sure, you are free to holler insults at your neighbor from your yard, but it does not mean that speech is free of consequences.

We all know there are exceptions to free speech. Usually when words can cause harm: a panic, violence, lies about others, etc. So this bright young cop was fantastic! Finally, right? He came, talked to them, then left but told me to call again if they said anything about race, or threatened me.

Oh, my neighbor obliged. As soon as the cop left, he helpfully shouted at one of my security cams “she’ll wish she were [ducking] dead.” Bam. Harassment and Terroristic Threats.

The day I described last time, with my loud mouth and criminally awesome dance moves, was a week before his hearing on that charge. He had pleaded not guilty. So, when the cops came, the female neighbor and pals went to work!

The next evening, Stanman and I were sitting on our couch, around 10ish. Watching Star Trek: TNG on Netflix. Again in my pajamas. And then this knock. The one you hear in every crime show. The “It’s the police, open up!” knock. I went out onto the porch to talk to them. It all seemed wrong. There were four cops on my stairs. They looked like the SS. Black outfits, all holstered up. One particular future Einsatzgruppen member did the identification thing and told me I had to come with them on a 302 Emergency Commitment Order.

That is when I knew the whole thing was BaloneyΒ  Sandwich. A 302 is a court order that allows a person who is a physical threat to themselves or others, or cannot take care of themselves to be committed to a mental institution against their will. They are difficult to obtain for the obvious reason that it is a power that could be abused (eh-hem). Normally, a social worker, someone from CRISIS, or a therapist/psychiatrist would initiate or weigh in on this. My therapist was not contacted. Often they are requested by family. And you cannot break into someone’s residence for a 302 unless there is an emergent situation, such as screaming or fighting. We were watching Trek. Mox nix, right?

I had been 302’d once before. I attempted suicide by taking a ton of NyQuil and Benadryl. My Mom and sister found me and took me to the hospital. I came around. I was still free. Not in restraints. But I was so angry, I hissed “I wish you let me die!” at my Mom. My Mom was a social worker, who worked with probation or parolees with mental health, drug/alcohol, or developmental disabilities. All minor offenders, but she knew the system.

Mom looked at the ER doctor and nodded, and then I was restrained. The place I went was more One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest than Girl, Interrupted. But basically, you have 3-5 days to be seen by a doctor and case worker, and have a meeting to judge whether you are still a threat or not. If you are calm, do what they say, and stick to yourself, it is not hard to get out of. You have to be very badly off to be committed in the long term.

So I knew how it worked as well. I knew the mental health system in general. I had been in it since about 19. My female neighbor wrote up something that basically said I had mental health issues and broke things on her lawn. (Because she called our house “the tenants’ house,” remember?)

It was delivered by Officer Einsatzgruppen to a Crisis worker, with access to all of my health records including my current treatment, whom I had never seen before or spoken with, and was a prison secretary to sign. And then the head of the County’s mental health board signed it without seeing or speaking to me either. (I see you Angie Krepps Alvarez! Sharon Harlacher! mwah!😘)

After hemming and hawing for an hour, and mentioning my neighbors on the darned Ring cam in plain sight (shrewd!). Then they broke down our door. Stan had already called 911 because he didn’t think they were real police either. They cuffed Stan, cuffed me, almost let our dog and cat out, and took me to a cruiser. Or some kind of car, it was dark. And I just resolved to stay calm. Losing my temper, being cranky, anything could have led to my actually being committed or jailed.

It is one of the odd consequences of PTSD that in the worst moments I don’t feel much. It seems like I am not me. I am somewhere floating above, or buried deep inside, or watching a movie of a life. So it was with this. I began to go down a thought hole of what may have happened to Stan. I pulled hard out of that downward trajectory. I could not think of anything else but breathing and remaining calm.

The doctors were confused from the beginning as to why I was there. They asked about my neighbors, and I said we had an ongoing dispute but I had no idea why I was in the hospital. And neither did the doctors. They couldn’t even find the legal order to commit me. From the hospital where the thing was written. Why they did not ask for it when I arrived is a question. But by 6am I was in the jeep back home with Stan, who they uncuffed and left to call every hospital looking for me.

We were home as the sun came up, we had a beer and went to bed. When we woke up it had sunk in. The extent of the violation. The broken door. The fact that four cops could be spared to take me to the hospital on a vendetta. But that night our neighbors effectively said, “We can touch you anywhere.” The same chill, creepy, skeevy feeling crept over me as other times with them.

We realized we were not safe in our own house. We couldn’t even call the police. So we packed a few important things, got our dog and cat, and drove to my Great Grandma’s house where family still lived, across the bridge in Lancaster County.

I took a selfie that next day.

Stress rashes around the mouth are sexy.

The male neighbor changed his plea to guilty (freedom is wasted on him), so I couldn’t give this information as testimony that next Monday. He was fined $50.

So, yeah, that is my story of how far my neighbors and my community went in their hatred of I do not know what. Stan and I spent the next month and half packing and cleaning for dear life. He started looking for new jobs far away. We looked at a couple of states before we decided. But he had to empty his retirement fund to finance this move, start a new job, find a new house, and sell the old.

The funny thing this whole time is that the male neighbor used to sit up by his garage (the better to see me from) and listen to John Denver’s “Thank God I’m a Country Boy.” I love that song! Who doesn’t like John Denver? He hung out with muppets!

The irony is that I AM from the country. My sister and I mainly grew up on two different farms in New Jersey. We had lots of acres, and would ramble about with our big white Lab, playing pretend. I collected the eggs. My sister tossed in scratch. We had turkeys. At one point we had a goat. I am a country girl, who spent a chunk of time in cities and abroad, but I am still as outdoorsy as ever.

They hated a phantom of their own imaginings. An idea of me. Not me as I am. And they would have gotten around to hating us for something if their Rottweiler had not have killed my duck.

They took nearly everything I loved: my chicken ladies, my ducks, my gardening, my peace, and they reached right in that house and tried to take my freedom.

So, we left that house at 6pm on New Year’s Eve to the booming of fireworks. Hours later, we checked into this hotel. And here I have been. But it will not be for much longer. I have had some time to process, through these blogs partly.

The harassment continued until we left, with gems like this:

Mmmm! Defamatory! You cannot even get cash assistance in that state if you are not a parent or a primary care giver. Stupid will stupid.

But here is the actual tragedy. While those four cops were busy sending me to the hospital, a bare week later they let a mother of two’s Emergency Protected from Abuse order wait 24 hrs before acting on it. And that night her ex-husband (and ex-cop) kidnapped those little girls. He eventually shot them and himself in a ditch on the side of the road. And that mother has not received any response or justice that I know of since. They had officers enough for me, but not to enough to save that woman’s babies.

I had that sign down after some phone calls. My life has sucked for so long. But things are happening. Soonish. I should have the tools by now to heal and reframe the stories I tell myself, question the words and names used to describe me, maybe that is why I made it out. That same mechanism that kicked in when I was being cuffed and taken to the hospital. Or maybe I am finally letting it sink in that it was them not us. Not me.

– JL βœŒπŸΌπŸ’šπŸ––πŸΌπŸ’πŸ’ͺπŸΌπŸ•ΊπŸ»πŸŽΈπŸ¦€

Check out my Instagram!! And connect with me on Facebook here and here.

Got a COMMENT? Click below! I love the feedback. If you like what you’ve read, TAP the Star LIKE button below. LIKE and SHARE on Facebook. Follow and share on Twitter